Just hiding this away for review - it will emerge again.
Breathes there the girl
« on: November 11, 2006, 09:30:15 AM » by Lavonne Westbrooks
At twelve I learned to breathe a poem.
It took me weeks but in the end
the words came forth upon their own.
The moment I stood before the class
reciting lines to help me pass
tears filled my eyes. I understood!
My teacher said I sounded scared.
She did not expect to find I cared
for the meaning in the words.
So came a zero from her pen
and laughter from the children
Yet doubly dying as I did that day
I could not turn from poesy's sway.
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 68.155.166.97 (?)
"I may be a sheep, but I'm pissed off and I don't run in a herd."
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #1 on: November 11, 2006, 09:39:19 AM » by milner place
Rhyming it this way is so apt for the subject. I wondered if to escape the inversion in the last line, you coudn't use 'poetry' as a rhyme for 'day'? 'I couldn't turn away from poetry.' Could use 'my back on').
milner
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 84.66.132.25 (?)
'Caminante, no hay camino,
se hace camino al andar'
- Antonio Machado
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #2 on: November 11, 2006, 09:46:32 AM » by Lavonne Westbrooks
Yes! I'll think on that. I want the right number of syllables in that end line.
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 68.155.166.97 (?)
"I may be a sheep, but I'm pissed off and I don't run in a herd."
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #3 on: November 11, 2006, 01:44:57 PM » by Vasile Baghiu
A very beautiful and poem, Lavonne!
Vasile
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 85.1.219.162 (?)
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #4 on: November 11, 2006, 01:47:04 PM » by Lynn Doiron
I like this, lavonne -- but also have a problem with that end line; it seems more natural for "I could not turn away" to open the line. I'm wondering if "from poetry" might be altered somehow --"from sonnet's sway" -- I dunno. "from word and rhyme" "from rhyme and poem"
lynn
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 70.136.40.171 (?)
lynndoiron.wordpress.com for memoir/journal/poetry blog
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #5 on: November 11, 2006, 02:21:09 PM » by Lavonne Westbrooks
Thanks all. I always thought the end line was very weak. It took a few new eyes to set me straight. Lynn, your suggestion was perfect. I have the correct number of syllables and a much stronger line.
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 68.155.166.97 (?)
"I may be a sheep, but I'm pissed off and I don't run in a herd."
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #6 on: November 11, 2006, 11:44:44 PM » by Lynn Doiron
*grin*
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 70.136.40.171 (?)
lynndoiron.wordpress.com for memoir/journal/poetry blog
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #7 on: Today at 11:14:08 AM » by Lavonne Westbrooks
With all this sonnet talk going around, I thought I'd pull this out to work on. I've replaced the word sonnet in the last line with poesy.
I can count on one hand the number of rhyming poems I've written and this one has some meter problems.
Any suggestions gang?
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 67.34.247.20 (?)
"I may be a sheep, but I'm pissed off and I don't run in a herd."
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #8 on: Today at 12:35:04 PM » by maggie flanagan-wilkie
el vee,
Head into meterland with this el, vee.
I learned to spit out poetry at twelve* IP
I got a chill from poetry at twelve. ** Tetrameter
The difference between the two is in how you scan the word poetry,
with one or two prominent stresses.
Mugs
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 207.200.116.11 (?)
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #9 on: Today at 01:37:22 PM » by silent lotus
Dear Lavonne
if there is an unstudied poet here at the circle
then it is certainly me......so i am in no position
to offer assistance here ......
yet
i should like to say that the beauty of the sentiment expressed
is one that i find compassionate to the soul of poet Greenwolfe
and so many other poets who truly care for the universe
of the creative voice
i hope that whatever revisions may come
that the essence of your message does not
become diminished.
thank you for resurrecting your poem
from the archives
and that you will one day also share
this with us at Buddah's tea house
silent lotus
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 96.238.20.75 (?)
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #10 on: Today at 04:10:53 PM » by Lynn Doiron
So pleased to see this back, lavonne. [Will let the meter experts play with what may need helpl -- I'm useless in that area]. The rhyme fits the age, nostalgia, voice. A treat. lynn
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 201.170.180.162 (?)
lynndoiron.wordpress.com for memoir/journal/poetry blog
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #11 on: Today at 04:20:36 PM » by maggie flanagan-wilkie
sl,
Why would you bring up greenwolfe's soul in a thread that should be addressing lavonne's concern with her poem and only that?
If you try and stay on track in the submit, editor's pick and front page threads, less time would be wasted in reading non-essential dialogue that belongs in discusions or pms.
Sidebars have no place in threads when writers are expecting
poet-speak from reviewers which lavonne indicated was her
purpose in reviving this thread.
You yourself say, in the quoted text below, that you are unstudied
and in no position to offer assistence to lavonne in this thread.
A simple I like this lavonne, or anyone else whose poem you read in the future
would serve the poet.
Maggie
Quote
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #9 on: Today at 01:37:22 PM » by silent lotus
Dear Lavonne
if there is an unstudied poet here at the circle
then it is certainly me......so i am in no position
to offer assistance here ......
yet
i should like to say that the beauty of the sentiment expressed
is one that i find compassionate to the soul of poet Greenwolfe
and so many other poets who truly care for the universe
of the creative voice
i hope that whatever revisions may come
that the essence of your message does not
become diminished.
thank you for resurrecting your poem
from the archives
and that you will one day also share
this with us at Buddah's tea house
silent lotus
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 207.200.116.11 (?)
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #12 on: Today at 04:29:20 PM » by Lavonne Westbrooks
Mugs,
Thanks for the road sign. I've been reading it over and over this afternoon. Trying to decide accents/stresses. This is helping me - lots.
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 67.34.247.20 (?)
"I may be a sheep, but I'm pissed off and I don't run in a herd."
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #13 on: Today at 04:34:27 PM » by silent lotus
Quote from: maggie flanagan-wilkie on Today at 04:20:36 PM
sl,
Why would you bring up greenwolfe's soul in a thread that should be addressing lavonne's concern with her poem and only that?
If you try and stay on track in the submit, editor's pick and front page threads, less time would be wasted in reading non-essential dialogue that belongs in discusions or pms.
Sidebars have no place in threads when writers are expecting
poet-speak from reviewers which lavonne indicated was her
purpose in reviving this thread.
You yourself say, in the quoted text below, that you are unstudied
and in no position to offer assistence to lavonne in this thread.
A simple I like this lavonne, or anyone else whose poem you read in the future
would serve the poet.
Maggie
Dear Maggie
Thank you for the tongue lashing.
Yet as i remember it Greenwolfe is a friend of Lavonne's
and came to this site at her invitation.
How unfortunate that my attempt at being
positive about him as well as other poets,
and my way of expressing my most positive appreciation for Lavonne's poem
does not sit well with you in your world.
silent lotus
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 96.238.20.75 (?)
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #14 on: Today at 05:11:20 PM » by Tom Riordan
Very curious little poem, Lavonne. Very girl-like indeed. Compellingly interesting. I'm not crazy about "poesy" for "poetry," seems either too seriously lofty or too facetiously lofty to me. Unclear to me: did N never recite the poem, or did she recite it fear- and tear-fully, and got a zero for that? -Tom
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 68.163.242.226 (?)
Move Topic | Remove Topic | Lock topic | Set topic sticky | Merge Topics | Link to Calendar |
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #15 on: Today at 05:22:20 PM » by Lavonne Westbrooks
I got it out - tearfully and fearfully - she thought I didn't know it but it was burned in my heart and emotion overcame me. Really - it's not very good - I just feel I should expand my horizon! It used to say sonnet but that didn't seem right either. Anyway, isn't poesy just the type of word a girl would use? Smiley
Breathes there the man, with soul so dead,
Who never to himself hath said,
"This is my own, my native land!"
Whose heart hath ne'er within him burned,
As home his footsteps he hath turned,
From wandering on a foreign strand!
If such there breathe, go, mark him well;
For him no Minstrel raptures swell;
High though his titles, proud his name,
Boundless his wealth as wish can claim;
Despite those titles, power, and pelf,
The wretch, concentred all in self,
Living, shall forfeit fair renown,
And, doubly dying, shall go down
To the vile dust, from whence he sprung,
Unwept, unhonoured, and unsung.
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 67.34.247.20 (?)
"I may be a sheep, but I'm pissed off and I don't run in a herd."
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #16 on: Today at 05:33:53 PM » by Tom Riordan
She gave you a ZERO for that?? That's why I was confused, made no sense. Give me her name!
Yes, a girl might well write "poesy" but I want to see that omen of maturity that the poem is, after all, about. I don't read a sentimental girl infatuated with poetry as with a matinee idol, I read the beginning a mature poet.
--Tom
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 68.163.242.226 (?)
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #17 on: Today at 07:10:53 PM » by Lavonne Westbrooks
Teachers in the sixties - what can I say?
and That's why I'm duke-ing it out with this poem - the woman will win in the end! Smiley
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 67.34.247.20 (?)
"I may be a sheep, but I'm pissed off and I don't run in a herd."
Re: Breathes there the girl
« Reply #18 on: Today at 07:55:28 PM » by EMH
I remember my sophomore year, in an all girl's private school, reading a poem out loud and after I finished it the only thing the teacher asked me was, 'do you write poetry often?' I mumbled yes and quickly sat down. She gave me a D and said it was, 'for effort' because, 'it didn't have a rhyme scheme' (which wasn't required mind you).
I feel ya sista
Reply | Reply with quote | Modify | Remove | Split Topic
Report to moderator 75.105.19.107 (?)
"Then a very gentle voice in the distance said, "She must be labeled 'Lass, with care,' you know."
- Through the Looking Glass